Saturday, March 9, 2013

Group 5: Immigration, Education, and the Politics of Inclusion


1.     In “Subverting the Master(‘s) Syllabus,” Patrick Camangian states “By mystifying reality, schooling is able to promote the idea that if you are compliant enough and study hard in school, then you can “achieve,” you will not get “left behind,” and you can “race to the top.” Everything will be all right for you. You will not be poor, you will have a nice job; and you will be better than those “other” people you left behind in “that” community.”
How do you encourage students to succeed and work to the best of their abilities without seeming colonialist or succumbing to the promotion of the idealistic American dream?

2.     Patrick Camangian in “Subverting the Master(‘s) Syllabus” has shown how to translate personal experience into an American or World History class or an English classroom.  How can we adapt curriculum requirements set by state requirements in other classes to address personal experience and history?

3.      With such a heated debate about racism and legislation promoting segregation outside the classroom, how do we handle such issues inside the classroom?  How should we as teachers deal and balance opinions of students, parents, other teachers, administrative staff, and our own?  How do we do all of this without posing a detriment to the students’ education and future?

4.     In light of the Arizona state legislation in regards to ethnicity and of federal legislation in regards to Black Codes, why is xenophobia and racism still in existence despite claims of equal rights and opportunity?  How does this translate to the American dream?

5.  The Arizona state legislature backs their stance with claims of preventing ethnic hate.  Is this a solid defense, or is this just a thinly veiled excuse?  How do you teach ethnic studies without pitting one group against another and thus proving the state representatives wrong?


Image From:
http://thegrio.files.wordpress.com/2011/06/ethnic-studies-in-arizona.jpg?w=487

No comments:

Post a Comment